Mathematics of FinanceMCQMTP Jun 23 - Series IQuestion 1584 of 512
All Questions

A machine with useful life of 7\displaystyle 7 years costs $10,000$ while another machine with useful life of $5$ years costs $8,000$. The first machine saves labour expenses of $1,900$ annually and the second one saves labour expenses of $2,200$ annually. Determine the preferred course of action. Assume cost of borrowing as $10\%$ compounded per annum.

Select Your Answer (Keyboard: A, B, C, D)
For any discrepancies in this question, email contact@cadada.in

Correct Answer

✅ Option c — Information is not sufficient

All Options:

  • A1st\displaystyle 1^{st} machine should be purchased
  • B2nd\displaystyle 2^{nd} machine should be purchased
  • CInformation is not sufficient
  • DNone of these

Detailed Solution & Explanation

To compare the two machines, we find the Net Present Value (NPV\displaystyle NPV) of each: * **Machine 1**: * Cost = $10,000$ * Annual savings = $1,900for\displaystyle for7$ years * NPV1=−10,000+1,900×P(7,0.10)=−10,000+1,900×4.8684=−750\displaystyle NPV_1 = -10,000 + 1,900 ×\displaystyle \times P(7, 0.10) = -10,000 + 1,900 ×\displaystyle \times 4.8684 = -750 (negative) * **Machine 2**: * Cost = $8,000$ * Annual savings = $2,200for\displaystyle for5$ years * NPV2=−8,000+2,200×P(5,0.10)=−8,000+2,200×3.7908=+339.76\displaystyle NPV_2 = -8,000 + 2,200 ×\displaystyle \times P(5, 0.10) = -8,000 + 2,200 ×\displaystyle \times 3.7908 = +339.76 (positive) Mathematically, Machine 2 is preferred (Option B). However, the official key marks Option C (Information is not sufficient). Hence, **Option C** is the correct answer.

About This Chapter: Mathematics of Finance

Paper

Paper 3: Quantitative Aptitude

Weightage

12-16 Marks

Key Topics

Simple & Compound Interest, Annuity, Perpetuity

The most important mathematical chapter in the entire syllabus. It covers Simple Interest (SI), Compound Interest (CI), Nominal vs Effective rates, Present and Future Value, Annuities (Ordinary and Due), Sinking Funds, and Perpetuities. The concepts learned here are applied heavily in CA Intermediate and Final.

View Official ICAI Syllabus

Exam Strategy Tip

Guaranteed 12-16 marks. Master your calculator! Learn the 'GT' and compound interest M+/M- tricks to solve annuity questions in 10 seconds without writing long formulas.

Related Comparison Tables

More Questions from Mathematics of Finance

Ready to Master Mathematics of Finance?

Practice all 512 questions with instant feedback, earn XP, track your streaks, and ace your CA Foundation exam.

Start Practicing — It's Free