Home//Resources/Difference Between

FIFO vs LIFO Inventory Valuation: CA Foundation Accounts

The choice of inventory valuation method significantly affects Gross Profit, closing stock value, and reported income. FIFO and LIFO represent opposite assumptions about the flow of goods.

head-to-Head Comparison

BasisFIFO (First In First Out)LIFO (Last In First Out)
Core AssumptionGoods purchased FIRST are sold/used FIRSTGoods purchased LAST are sold/used FIRST
Closing Stock ValuationValued at LATEST (most recent) purchase pricesValued at OLDEST (earliest) purchase prices
COGS during InflationLower COGS (older, cheaper prices used) → Higher Gross ProfitHigher COGS (recent, costlier prices used) → Lower Gross Profit
Closing Stock during InflationHigher (valued at recent higher prices)Lower (valued at older lower prices)
AcceptanceAccepted under Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS 2) and IFRSNOT permitted under Ind AS 2 / IFRS; allowed under US GAAP

The 'LIFO is Banned in India' Trap

LIFO is prohibited under Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS 2 / AS 2) and under IFRS. However, it is still allowed under US GAAP. In the CA Foundation exam, if a question asks which method is 'not permitted' in India, the answer is LIFO. Do not confuse this with tax treatment.

Common Ground (Similarities)

  • Both are methods for determining the cost of inventory consumed (COGS) and closing stock.
  • Both result in the same total cost of goods available for sale.
  • Both affect the Balance Sheet (closing stock value) and P&L Account (Gross Profit) simultaneously.

Test Your Understanding

Q1: During a period of rising prices, FIFO will result in:

Lower Gross Profit than LIFO
Same Gross Profit as LIFO
Higher Gross Profit than LIFO
Zero Gross Profit
Explanation: FIFO uses cheaper (older) costs for COGS. Lower COGS means higher Gross Profit during inflation.

Q2: Under Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS 2), which method is NOT permitted?

FIFO
Weighted Average
LIFO
Specific Identification
Explanation: Ind AS 2 (Inventories) explicitly prohibits the LIFO method for valuing inventories in India.

"FIFO = First bought, first sold; Closing stock at recent prices; Ind AS compliant. LIFO = Last bought, first sold; Closing stock at old prices; NOT permitted in India."