FIFO vs LIFO Inventory Valuation: CA Foundation Accounts
The choice of inventory valuation method significantly affects Gross Profit, closing stock value, and reported income. FIFO and LIFO represent opposite assumptions about the flow of goods.
head-to-Head Comparison
| Basis | FIFO (First In First Out) | LIFO (Last In First Out) |
|---|---|---|
| Core Assumption | Goods purchased FIRST are sold/used FIRST | Goods purchased LAST are sold/used FIRST |
| Closing Stock Valuation | Valued at LATEST (most recent) purchase prices | Valued at OLDEST (earliest) purchase prices |
| COGS during Inflation | Lower COGS (older, cheaper prices used) → Higher Gross Profit | Higher COGS (recent, costlier prices used) → Lower Gross Profit |
| Closing Stock during Inflation | Higher (valued at recent higher prices) | Lower (valued at older lower prices) |
| Acceptance | Accepted under Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS 2) and IFRS | NOT permitted under Ind AS 2 / IFRS; allowed under US GAAP |
The 'LIFO is Banned in India' Trap
LIFO is prohibited under Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS 2 / AS 2) and under IFRS. However, it is still allowed under US GAAP. In the CA Foundation exam, if a question asks which method is 'not permitted' in India, the answer is LIFO. Do not confuse this with tax treatment.
Common Ground (Similarities)
- Both are methods for determining the cost of inventory consumed (COGS) and closing stock.
- Both result in the same total cost of goods available for sale.
- Both affect the Balance Sheet (closing stock value) and P&L Account (Gross Profit) simultaneously.
Test Your Understanding
Q1: During a period of rising prices, FIFO will result in:
Lower Gross Profit than LIFO
Same Gross Profit as LIFO
Higher Gross Profit than LIFO ✅
Zero Gross Profit
Explanation: FIFO uses cheaper (older) costs for COGS. Lower COGS means higher Gross Profit during inflation.
Q2: Under Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS 2), which method is NOT permitted?
FIFO
Weighted Average
LIFO ✅
Specific Identification
Explanation: Ind AS 2 (Inventories) explicitly prohibits the LIFO method for valuing inventories in India.