Auditing and EthicsSubjectiveQuestion 5667 of 212
All Questions

Question 1 (a) AP & Co., Chartered Accountants, are appointed as statutory auditor of Heavy Industries Limited, a listed company engaged in manufacturing of electric vehicles, for the F.Y. 2023-24. As per the recent guideline issued by the regulatory authority, every listed company is required to maintain the digital database of all those personnel who could access the books of the company to avoid Insider Trading. In case of non-compliance, hefty fines may be imposed on the company. CA P is the engagement partner from auditor firm for the audit of Heavy Industries Limited. During planning, CA P planned that he would inquire from in-house IT Head of the company about the maintenance of the digital database to identify and assess the risk of non- compliance with regulatory guidelines. In the light of above facts, explain : (i) Whether CA P is required to consider about the maintenance of digital database while framing audit strategy ? (3 Marks) (ii) Whether the procedures planned by CA P are in line with SA-300 ? (2 Marks) (b) Fashion Garments Limited (FOL) is a company engaged in the manufacturing and sale of ready-made garments. The products manufactured by FGL cater to clothing requirements of men, women and kids section. Pearl & Associates, Chartered Accountants, is the statutory auditor of FGL. Partner CA Pearl asked her audit assistant to go through the segment information disclosed and presented in the financial statements. Assistant is new to the audit engagements and seeks her guidance on what is the key responsibility of the auditor in relation to segment information. What should CA Pearl guide the assistant on the said matter ? (2 Marks) What audit procedures should CA Pearl perform to ensure that methods used by the management to present segment information are in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework ? (3 Marks) AUDITING AND ETHICS (c) Spare Parts Limited received an input from internal auditors that internal controls implemented by the company appears to be reasonable but not so strong that any fraudulent activity can be prevented or timely detected by such controls. Accordingly a qualified person should head the internal controls department. CA Raj has been appointed as an Internal Control Head of the company. His scope of work includes development of internal controls in various departments/areas of the company. On his joining, he studied the various verticals and after identifying the important areas (prone to fraud) implemented strong controls in those areas. In his meeting with senior management and statutory auditors, he assured that satisfactory control environment exists and fraud cannot happen. Whether existence of a satisfactory control environment can be considered as an absolute deterrent to fraud ? (4 Marks)

For any discrepancies in this question, email contact@cadada.in

Ad

Detailed Solution & Explanation

**(a) (i) Consideration of Digital Database in Audit Strategy:**
As per SA 300, "Planning an Audit of Financial Statements", the auditor should establish an overall audit strategy that sets the scope, timing, and direction of the audit, and that guides the development of the audit plan. Establishing the overall audit strategy assists the auditor to determine, subject to the completion of the risk assessment procedures, the key resources required to conduct the audit.

The auditor must consider factors that, in their professional judgment, are significant in directing the engagement team's efforts, including legal and regulatory requirements. In the case of Heavy Industries Limited, a listed company, maintaining a digital database of all personnel with access to the company's books is a mandatory regulatory guideline to prevent insider trading. Failure to comply results in hefty fines, which can significantly affect the financial statements or cause material non-compliance risk.

Therefore, CA P is required to consider the maintenance of this digital database and evaluate compliance with the regulatory requirement while framing the overall audit strategy.

**(a) (ii) Alignment of Planned Procedures with SA 300:**
As per SA 300, planning includes obtaining a general understanding of the legal and regulatory framework applicable to the entity and how the entity is complying with that framework. This is part of the risk assessment procedures prior to identifying and assessing the risks of material misstatement.

CA P's plan to inquire from the in-house IT Head of the company regarding the maintenance of the digital database is an appropriate procedure to understand whether the company has implemented the required controls to comply with regulatory guidelines. This inquiry helps CA P in obtaining the necessary understanding of the regulatory framework and the compliance status of the entity. Thus, the planned procedures are fully in line with SA 300.

**(b) Responsibility and Audit Procedures for Segment Information (SA 501):**
**Key Responsibility of the Auditor:**
Under SA 501, "Audit Evidence - Specific Considerations for Selected Items", the auditor's responsibility regarding the presentation and disclosure of segment information is in relation to the financial statements taken as a whole. The auditor is not required to perform audit procedures that would be necessary to express an opinion on segment information presented on a standalone basis.

**Audit Procedures to Ensure Compliance of Segment Information Methods:**
CA Pearl should perform the following procedures to ensure that the methods used by management are in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework:
1. Obtain an understanding of the methods used by management in determining segment information, and evaluate whether such methods are likely to result in disclosure in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework.
2. Perform analytical procedures or other audit procedures appropriate in the circumstances, which include:
- Reviewing sales, transfers, and charges between segments, and the elimination of intersegment amounts.
- Comparing segment information with budgets and other expected results, such as operating profits as a percentage of sales.
- Testing the allocation of assets and costs among segments.
- Checking consistency with prior periods, and the adequacy of disclosures with respect to inconsistencies.

**(c) Existence of Satisfactory Control Environment as a Deterrent to Fraud:**
No, the existence of a satisfactory control environment **cannot** be considered an absolute deterrent to fraud. While a strong control environment is a positive factor when assessing the risks of material misstatement, it has inherent limitations:
1. **Not an Absolute Deterrent**: Although it helps reduce the risk of fraud, it cannot completely prevent or detect all instances of fraud because controls can be bypassed through management override or collusion among employees.
2. **Impact of Deficiencies**: Deficiencies in the control environment can undermine the effectiveness of specific control activities. For example, if management fails to commit sufficient resources to address IT security risks, unauthorized transactions might be processed despite other controls being in place.
3. **Influence on Other Controls**: The control environment in itself does not prevent, or detect and correct, a material misstatement. However, it influences the auditor's evaluation of the effectiveness of other controls (such as the monitoring of controls and specific control activities) and thereby affects the auditor's assessment of risks.

Key Concepts to Understand

Fraud

A false representation of a material fact made by a party to a contract knowingly, without belief in its truth, or recklessly, with intent to deceive the other party or induce them to enter a contract (Section 17, ICA 1872). Contract is Voidable + right to claim damages.

More Questions from Auditing and Ethics

Sum of progression (a+b)\displaystyle (a+b), (a−b)\displaystyle (a-b), (a−3b)...n\displaystyle (a-3b)...n term is

Find the sum of first twenty-five terms of A.P. series whose nth\displaystyle n^{th} term is (n+25)\displaystyle \left(n+\frac{2}{5}\right)

The first and fifth term of an A.P. of 40\displaystyle 40 terms are −29\displaystyle -29 and −15\displaystyle -15 respectively. Find the sum of all positive terms of this A.P

If the common difference of an AP equals to the first term, then the ratio of its mth\displaystyle m^{th} term and nth\displaystyle n^{th} term is:

Find the value of 1+2+3+...+105\displaystyle 1+2+3+...+105

The first and last terms of an arithmetic progression are 5\displaystyle 5 and 905\displaystyle 905. Sum of the terms is 45,955\displaystyle 45,955. The number of terms is

Ready to Master Auditing and Ethics?

Practice all 212 questions with instant feedback, earn XP, track your streaks, and ace your CA Foundation exam.

Start Practicing — It's Free